{ "@context": "https://schema.org", "@type": "Dataset", "@id": "https://circleback.ai/compare/tldv-vs-read-ai#dataset", "schemaVersion": 4, "type": "SoftwareApplicationComparison", "slug": "tldv-vs-read-ai", "url": "https://circleback.ai/compare/tldv-vs-read-ai", "canonicalUrl": "https://circleback.ai/compare/tldv-vs-read-ai", "title": "tl;dv vs Read AI: pricing, features, and which is better", "description": "Compare tl;dv vs Read AI on pricing, notes, action items, recordings, capture, and integrations. Source-backed research with candid tradeoffs.", "inLanguage": "en-US", "isAccessibleForFree": true, "representations": { "html": "https://circleback.ai/compare/tldv-vs-read-ai", "markdown": "https://circleback.ai/compare/tldv-vs-read-ai.md", "json": "https://circleback.ai/compare/tldv-vs-read-ai.json", "describedBy": "https://circleback.ai/compare/llms.txt" }, "editorialPerspective": "Neutral competitor comparison; Circleback is presented only as a labeled third option.", "verdict": "tl;dv centers recordings, clips, reports, and playbooks. Read AI centers live engagement and sentiment analytics, coaching metrics, and search across connected work sources.", "products": [ { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "shortName": "tl;dv", "logoPath": "/marketing/comparisons/logos/tldv.png", "website": "https://tldv.io", "tagline": "A generous recorder with clips, multi-meeting reports, and increasingly sales-focused AI.", "positioning": "tl;dv combines unlimited meeting recording on its free tier with clips, reels, recurring reports, playbooks, and sales coaching. Its newer bot-free desktop mode broadens capture, but that mode is audio-only and drops video, screen share, and chat.", "bestFor": "Individuals and customer-facing teams that want a generous free recorder, easy clips, recurring multi-meeting reports, and optional sales playbooks.", "lessIdealFor": "Teams that need a mature mobile rollout, video in bot-free mode, stable API contracts, durable free-plan retention, or one cross-functional company context layer.", "decisionSummary": { "fit": "Free online recording, clips, and recurring reports", "chooseFor": [ "A generous free recorder", "Clips and sales playbooks" ], "watchFor": [ "Bot-free mode drops video and chat", "No bulk export; API is alpha" ] }, "pricing": { "headline": "Free; Pro from $18/user/month annually; Business from $29 annually", "detail": "Free includes unlimited recordings and transcripts, but recordings are retained for three months, older recordings are archived shortly after processing, advanced AI credits are lifetime-limited, and after the first ten meetings generated notes cover only the first ten minutes. Paid prices are per user/month: Pro is $18 with annual billing or $29 month-to-month; Business is $29 or $39. Enterprise is quoted separately.", "freePlan": "Yes: unlimited recordings and transcripts, with retention, archive, AI-note, credit, duration, and concurrency limits." }, "strengths": [ "One of the broadest free recording and transcription allowances, despite meaningful retention and AI-output limits.", "Strong clips, reels, highlights, multi-meeting reports, playbooks, and sales coaching workflows.", "Bot and bot-free macOS/Windows capture now sit beside an early mobile recorder for in-person conversations.", "Recurring AI reports and conditional Slack workflows are particularly good at turning many calls into a compact digest with decisions and owner/deadline action lists." ], "tradeoffs": [ "Bot-free capture is audio-only: no video, screen sharing, or meeting chat is preserved.", "The newly documented mobile recorder is still described as an early-stage testing experience rather than a mature production path.", "Free recordings are retained for three months and quickly archived; after the first ten meetings, generated notes cover only the first ten minutes.", "The public API is labeled v1alpha1, and MCP searches typically return at most 50 meetings per query.", "There is no bulk meeting export in the product. Individual recording downloads require both owner and downloader to be on a paid plan, plus editor or admin access.", "The domain-level Organization is automatic rather than a governed tenant: any same-domain user can join it and the Organization itself cannot be deleted. Paid Teams provide the actual admin hierarchy.", "Several advanced AI, sales, and multilingual capabilities are reserved for higher plans.", "tl;dv can extract assigned action lists and send them elsewhere, but it does not document a native workspace-wide task system with assignee queues, status, due dates, and completion tracking." ], "chooseIf": [ "Unlimited free recording matters more than unlimited AI notes.", "Your workflow revolves around clips, playlists, sales playbooks, and recurring topic reports.", "You are comfortable using a bot when video, screen share, and chat need to be retained." ], "features": { "capture": { "summary": "Meeting bot or bot-free desktop recording", "detail": "macOS and Windows can capture system audio from any meeting platform without a bot. The bot remains the richer mode for supported conferencing platforms.", "level": "strong" }, "platforms": { "summary": "Web, Chrome, macOS, Windows, and an early mobile app", "detail": "Desktop capture is broad. tl;dv now documents a mobile app for in-person meetings, but describes it as recently launched, early-stage, and available for testing.", "level": "available" }, "inPerson": { "summary": "Desktop microphone or early-stage mobile recording", "detail": "A laptop can capture room audio and the newer mobile app can record in-person meetings. tl;dv documents speaker identification generally but does not explain whether the early mobile path preserves the same naming behavior, so test it before a broad rollout. There is no documented Watch capture.", "level": "available" }, "recordings": { "summary": "Rich playback, clips, and reels—with a botless video caveat", "detail": "Bot recordings support video, transcript, clips, reels, and shareable moments. Bot-free recordings are audio-only and omit video, screen sharing, and chat.", "level": "strong" }, "notesAndSearch": { "summary": "AI notes, action digests, multi-meeting reports, and topic tracking", "detail": "The product is particularly good at synthesizing multiple meetings and turning recurring prompts into reports, including action lists grouped by person and date. Those are report or checklist outputs rather than a native task lifecycle with workspace queues and completion state. Free accounts get a limited number of AI notes.", "level": "strong" }, "companyMemory": { "summary": "Meeting library and multi-meeting synthesis", "detail": "tl;dv can query and report across accessible meetings, but it does not present a broader email/calendar/person/company relationship memory as its core model.", "level": "available" }, "sharing": { "summary": "Granular team privacy defaults and automatic sharing", "detail": "Teams can automatically share with participants, publish to a team or organization library, and apply admin privacy rules using meeting context such as title, internal or external type, and team role. Sensitive categories can remain private by rule.", "level": "strong" }, "automations": { "summary": "Recurring AI reports and sales workflows", "detail": "Automated multi-meeting reports, playbooks, CRM updates, and conditional Slack posts are useful, especially for customer-facing teams. Slack workflows can format decisions and action items with owners and deadlines, but team workflow scope excludes team admins and billing-group admins, and the overall system is less open-ended than a general meeting condition/action builder.", "level": "strong" }, "integrations": { "summary": "CRM and collaboration integrations on paid plans", "detail": "tl;dv connects to common CRMs and work tools; exact access varies by plan. The catalog is oriented around GTM and collaboration workflows.", "level": "available" }, "agentsAndApi": { "summary": "MCP on Pro+ and a public alpha API", "detail": "MCP can search meetings and participants, with typical result sets capped at 50. A subtle access rule matters: viewing a shared meeting is not enough if its organizer is on Free—the organizer must have Pro or higher before that meeting is available through MCP or the API. The API is documented as v1alpha1 and includes recording downloads, so integration teams should expect contract evolution.", "level": "available" }, "admin": { "summary": "Paid Team controls, with a looser domain Organization layer", "detail": "Paid Teams add roles, billing administration, and forward-looking defaults; team settings do not override Team Admins. The separate domain-based Organization has no organization-wide admin defaults, any same-domain user can join it, and it cannot be deleted. Multi-team management is Business-only.", "level": "available" }, "languages": { "summary": "Multilingual transcription; advanced multilingual mode is plan-gated", "detail": "Language selection behavior varies by capture mode, and the multilingual Whisper option is documented for Business and Enterprise.", "level": "available" } }, "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv pricing", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6082483-what-is-tl-dv-s-pricing", "note": "Official Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise pricing and plan scope." }, { "label": "tl;dv free-plan limits", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8919450-what-are-the-limits-of-the-free-plan", "note": "Recording retention, archive behavior, AI-note coverage, lifetime credits, meeting duration, and concurrency." }, { "label": "tl;dv mobile app", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8490450-mobile-app", "note": "Recently launched early-stage mobile recording for in-person meetings." }, { "label": "tl;dv speaker identification", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6171907-speaker-identification-in-transcript", "note": "General automatic speaker identification; the article does not document mobile-mode parity." }, { "label": "tl;dv bot-free recording", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/14433337-recording-without-a-bot", "note": "Desktop capture and the audio-only limitation." }, { "label": "tl;dv MCP", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15322415-mcp", "note": "Plan eligibility, tools, access model, and result behavior." }, { "label": "tl;dv API", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/11583137-api", "note": "Pro/Business eligibility and v1alpha1 status." }, { "label": "tl;dv team privacy defaults", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15033798-team-privacy-defaults", "note": "Admin-controlled automatic sharing, workspace-library publishing, and privacy rules for sensitive meetings." }, { "label": "tl;dv download limits", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/5946213-how-to-download-your-recording", "note": "No bulk export plus paid-plan, ownership, and permission requirements for individual recording downloads." }, { "label": "tl;dv organization and team model", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8975481-organization-vs-team-what-s-the-difference", "note": "Automatic same-domain Organization membership, absence of Organization-wide admin defaults, and the paid Team hierarchy." }, { "label": "tl;dv permission levels", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/10131073-understanding-permission-levels", "note": "Team roles, admin behavior, and the non-deletable domain Organization." }, { "label": "tl;dv AI prompts", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/9235713-ai-prompts-inspiration", "note": "Cross-meeting action-item reports grouped by participant and date plus common analysis workflows." }, { "label": "tl;dv Slack workflows", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/5946410-set-up-the-slack-integration", "note": "Conditional automatic summaries, decisions, and owner/deadline action lists plus the team-admin scope exception." } ] }, { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "shortName": "Read AI", "logoPath": "/marketing/comparisons/logos/read-ai.png", "website": "https://www.read.ai", "tagline": "Meeting summaries plus live engagement analytics and search across workplace content.", "positioning": "Read AI goes beyond notes with live engagement, sentiment, speaker metrics, Search Copilot, and access across meetings and other work sources. Its pricing looks approachable until recording playback and governance requirements push a team into Enterprise tiers.", "bestFor": "Teams that value live engagement/sentiment signals, speaker analytics, coaching, and a search assistant spanning multiple workplace content sources.", "lessIdealFor": "Teams that want recordings on ordinary plans, dislike behavioral scoring in meetings, need free viewer economics, or want simple transparent governance below Enterprise+.", "decisionSummary": { "fit": "Live engagement, sentiment, and speaker analytics", "chooseFor": [ "Manager coaching signals", "Cross-tool workplace search" ], "watchFor": [ "Playback requires Enterprise", "API/MCP beta; no static keys" ] }, "pricing": { "headline": "Free for 5 meetings/month; Pro from $15/user/month annually", "detail": "Prices are per user/month: Pro is $15 with annual billing or $19.75 month-to-month; Enterprise is $22.50 or $29.75 and adds playback; Enterprise+ is $29.75 or $39.75 and adds advanced retention, domain, SAML, and HIPAA-related options, with a five-license minimum.", "freePlan": "Yes: five meetings per month." }, "strengths": [ "Distinctive live engagement, sentiment, speaker, and meeting-quality analytics.", "Search Copilot reaches beyond meetings into connected email, messaging, and document sources.", "Automatic recaps and recurring-meeting pre-reads can carry action items and open questions into email, Slack, or Teams.", "Current macOS/Windows desktop plus iOS and Android in-person capture broaden the product beyond a meeting bot.", "Its open-beta REST API and MCP expose full speaker-labeled transcripts, summaries, actions, metrics, and recording download URLs for meetings the user can access." ], "tradeoffs": [ "Audio/video playback requires Enterprise or Enterprise+, while lower-tier source media is deleted after the documented grace period.", "Advanced retention, SAML, domain controls, and HIPAA support require Enterprise+ and its license minimum.", "Engagement and sentiment scoring can be useful for coaching but uncomfortable or noisy for some company cultures.", "Workspace licensing does not offer the same free-viewer model as some competitors.", "The API and MCP are open beta: OAuth tokens are short-lived, static keys/client credentials are not supported, and several app features and file upload are not exposed.", "Read says meeting data is not used for AI training without explicit opt-in, but its Customer Experience Improvement Program is enabled on an opt-out basis for product evaluation.", "Simply removing a person from a workspace does not revoke their account access or transfer their reports. Admins must deactivate the account and transfer workspace-owned reports as separate offboarding steps." ], "chooseIf": [ "Live engagement and speaker analytics are genuinely useful to your managers or facilitators.", "You want AI search across meetings plus connected workplace sources.", "You are comfortable with Enterprise pricing for playback and Enterprise+ for stronger governance." ], "features": { "capture": { "summary": "Meeting bot, macOS/Windows desktop, and mobile", "detail": "The assistant can join scheduled calls, while desktop records device audio without relying solely on a bot. Disclosure and opt-out flows remain part of the participant experience.", "level": "strong" }, "platforms": { "summary": "Web, macOS, Windows, iOS, and Android", "detail": "Desktop captures device audio for online meetings. The iPhone and Android apps record in-person conversations and put their reports beside Zoom, Meet, and Teams meetings; neither mobile app can record another app or phone call using the same microphone.", "level": "strong" }, "inPerson": { "summary": "iOS and Android real-time transcript and summary", "detail": "Both mobile apps record room conversations with a live transcript and summary. They do not capture phone calls, FaceTime, or a virtual-meeting app on the same device. In shared-room audio, distinct voices may begin as Conference Room — Speaker 1, Speaker 2, and so on; owners and editors can rename or reassign them afterward.", "level": "strong" }, "recordings": { "summary": "Playback only on Enterprise and Enterprise+", "detail": "Pro and free users can receive notes and transcripts, but source media is not a durable playback library. Read documents a 30-day grace period before lower-tier media deletion.", "level": "limited" }, "notesAndSearch": { "summary": "Summaries, action items, Search Copilot, and coaching analytics", "detail": "Read’s differentiated layer is live and post-meeting intelligence: engagement, sentiment, speaker stats, action items, and search across connected content. Recommendations can resurface recent work assigned to the user, but Read does not document a full workspace-wide task board with assignee and completion management comparable to dedicated action trackers.", "level": "strong" }, "companyMemory": { "summary": "Cross-source Search Copilot", "detail": "Search can span meetings, email, messages, and documents, which is broader than a transcript library. The experience is a search layer rather than explicit relationship timelines and upcoming-event pages.", "level": "strong" }, "sharing": { "summary": "Workspace-wide participant and team report access", "detail": "Workspace admins can set automatic report access for internal or external participants and give teams role-based access to matching reports, including retroactive access. Owners can send recaps and recurring-meeting pre-reads through email, Slack, or Teams. Participant rules use calendar invitees, including no-shows, and the owner’s settings govern each report, so teams should configure workspace controls deliberately.", "level": "strong" }, "automations": { "summary": "Recaps, pre-reads, scheduled updates, and agent actions", "detail": "Read can send post-meeting recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and scheduled topic updates, while Ask Read actions can draft and send email, create calendar events, and update HubSpot after user approval. It is more opinionated around its own agents and intelligence outputs than a general meeting trigger/condition/action canvas.", "level": "available" }, "integrations": { "summary": "Calendar, conferencing, email, messaging, documents, and premium connectors", "detail": "Search Copilot’s cross-source coverage is a strength, although connector eligibility varies by paid plan.", "level": "strong" }, "agentsAndApi": { "summary": "Open-beta REST API and MCP with full meeting reports", "detail": "Read’s API and remote MCP can return meeting metadata, participants, summaries, chapters, action items, topics, metrics, full speaker-labeled transcripts, and recording-download URLs. They are open beta, use browser OAuth with short-lived rotating tokens, lack service credentials and file upload, and only reach reports the user can access unless an admin enables global report access.", "level": "available" }, "admin": { "summary": "Core admin on Enterprise; advanced governance on Enterprise+", "detail": "Retention, domain controls, SAML, and HIPAA-related capabilities are concentrated in Enterprise+. That plan currently carries a five-license minimum.", "level": "strong" }, "languages": { "summary": "Read’s pricing page says 20+; its detail table says 16+", "detail": "Read’s current pricing page uses “20+ languages” in the Free plan card but “16+ languages” in the detailed comparison table. The coverage is useful but materially narrower on paper than competitors advertising 75 or 100+; verify the language you need rather than relying on the headline count.", "level": "available" } }, "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." }, { "label": "Read AI desktop app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/45911611006995-How-to-Use-Read-s-Desktop-App-for-Windows-and-Mac", "note": "Device-audio recording and participant disclosure behavior." }, { "label": "Read AI iPhone app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/34467337929107-Read-AI-App-for-iPhone", "note": "In-person real-time transcript and summary." }, { "label": "Read AI Android app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/51863250182291-Read-AI-App-for-Android", "note": "Android in-person capture, live transcript and summary, and report access." }, { "label": "Read AI mobile capture limits", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/51863422605203-Can-I-use-Read-s-mobile-app-to-record-calls-from-my-phone", "note": "Phone-call and same-device virtual-meeting limitations across iOS and Android." }, { "label": "Read AI speaker editing", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/36169538719379-Can-I-edit-text-and-speaker-names-in-my-meeting-report", "note": "Generic same-room labels plus transcript-wide speaker renaming and turn reassignment." }, { "label": "Read AI recording availability", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/15107171454739-Why-can-t-I-see-recordings-in-my-report-when-I-received-a-recording-notification-in-my-meeting", "note": "Enterprise playback requirement and lower-plan source-media deletion." }, { "label": "Read AI workspace sharing settings", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/7962819152659-What-are-all-of-the-settings-and-permissions-available-with-Workspaces", "note": "Participant auto-sharing, team report access, and workspace distribution controls." }, { "label": "Read AI report distribution", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/23219401248019-How-do-I-control-meeting-report-sharing-and-distribution", "note": "Owner-level participant sharing, invitee behavior, email/Slack/Teams recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and workspace controls." }, { "label": "Read AI actions", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/48863788829971-Using-Ask-Read-actions", "note": "Agent actions for HubSpot updates, approved email sending, calendar creation, and scheduled reports." }, { "label": "Read AI API and MCP overview", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/49379985941523-Read-AI-API-and-MCP-Overview", "note": "Open-beta scope, prerequisites, OAuth and rate-limit constraints, permissions, and current feature gaps." }, { "label": "Read AI MCP tools", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/49381158409491-MCP-Server", "note": "Full transcript, summary, action, metric, recording-download, agent-dispatch, and sharing tools." }, { "label": "Read AI data handling", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/52055801266579-What-Does-Read-AI-Do-With-My-Data-Read-AI", "note": "Storage, access, AI-training consent, and the opt-out Customer Experience Improvement Program." }, { "label": "Read AI workspace offboarding", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/27433066427283-How-do-I-offboard-someone-from-my-Read-workspace", "note": "Account deactivation, report transfer, and the limits of simply removing a workspace member." } ] } ], "dimensions": [ { "key": "capture", "label": "Capture options", "lead": "Both products document broad support for capture options, with different scope and plan limits.", "analysis": "tl;dv: macOS and Windows can capture system audio from any meeting platform without a bot. The bot remains the richer mode for supported conferencing platforms. Read AI: The assistant can join scheduled calls, while desktop records device audio without relying solely on a bot. Disclosure and opt-out flows remain part of the participant experience.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Meeting bot or bot-free desktop recording", "detail": "macOS and Windows can capture system audio from any meeting platform without a bot. The bot remains the richer mode for supported conferencing platforms.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv bot-free recording", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/14433337-recording-without-a-bot", "note": "Desktop capture and the audio-only limitation." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Meeting bot, macOS/Windows desktop, and mobile", "detail": "The assistant can join scheduled calls, while desktop records device audio without relying solely on a bot. Disclosure and opt-out flows remain part of the participant experience.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI desktop app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/45911611006995-How-to-Use-Read-s-Desktop-App-for-Windows-and-Mac", "note": "Device-audio recording and participant disclosure behavior." } ] } }, { "key": "platforms", "label": "Desktop and mobile", "lead": "Read AI has broader documented support for desktop and mobile.", "analysis": "tl;dv: Desktop capture is broad. tl;dv now documents a mobile app for in-person meetings, but describes it as recently launched, early-stage, and available for testing. Read AI: Desktop captures device audio for online meetings. The iPhone and Android apps record in-person conversations and put their reports beside Zoom, Meet, and Teams meetings; neither mobile app can record another app or phone call using the same microphone.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Web, Chrome, macOS, Windows, and an early mobile app", "detail": "Desktop capture is broad. tl;dv now documents a mobile app for in-person meetings, but describes it as recently launched, early-stage, and available for testing.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv bot-free recording", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/14433337-recording-without-a-bot", "note": "Desktop capture and the audio-only limitation." }, { "label": "tl;dv mobile app", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8490450-mobile-app", "note": "Recently launched early-stage mobile recording for in-person meetings." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Web, macOS, Windows, iOS, and Android", "detail": "Desktop captures device audio for online meetings. The iPhone and Android apps record in-person conversations and put their reports beside Zoom, Meet, and Teams meetings; neither mobile app can record another app or phone call using the same microphone.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI desktop app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/45911611006995-How-to-Use-Read-s-Desktop-App-for-Windows-and-Mac", "note": "Device-audio recording and participant disclosure behavior." }, { "label": "Read AI iPhone app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/34467337929107-Read-AI-App-for-iPhone", "note": "In-person real-time transcript and summary." }, { "label": "Read AI Android app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/51863250182291-Read-AI-App-for-Android", "note": "Android in-person capture, live transcript and summary, and report access." } ] } }, { "key": "inPerson", "label": "In-person capture and speaker labels", "lead": "Read AI has broader documented support for in-person capture and speaker labels.", "analysis": "tl;dv: A laptop can capture room audio and the newer mobile app can record in-person meetings. tl;dv documents speaker identification generally but does not explain whether the early mobile path preserves the same naming behavior, so test it before a broad rollout. There is no documented Watch capture. Read AI: Both mobile apps record room conversations with a live transcript and summary. They do not capture phone calls, FaceTime, or a virtual-meeting app on the same device. In shared-room audio, distinct voices may begin as Conference Room — Speaker 1, Speaker 2, and so on; owners and editors can rename or reassign them afterward.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Desktop microphone or early-stage mobile recording", "detail": "A laptop can capture room audio and the newer mobile app can record in-person meetings. tl;dv documents speaker identification generally but does not explain whether the early mobile path preserves the same naming behavior, so test it before a broad rollout. There is no documented Watch capture.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv mobile app", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8490450-mobile-app", "note": "Recently launched early-stage mobile recording for in-person meetings." }, { "label": "tl;dv speaker identification", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6171907-speaker-identification-in-transcript", "note": "General automatic speaker identification; the article does not document mobile-mode parity." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "iOS and Android real-time transcript and summary", "detail": "Both mobile apps record room conversations with a live transcript and summary. They do not capture phone calls, FaceTime, or a virtual-meeting app on the same device. In shared-room audio, distinct voices may begin as Conference Room — Speaker 1, Speaker 2, and so on; owners and editors can rename or reassign them afterward.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI iPhone app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/34467337929107-Read-AI-App-for-iPhone", "note": "In-person real-time transcript and summary." }, { "label": "Read AI Android app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/51863250182291-Read-AI-App-for-Android", "note": "Android in-person capture, live transcript and summary, and report access." }, { "label": "Read AI mobile capture limits", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/51863422605203-Can-I-use-Read-s-mobile-app-to-record-calls-from-my-phone", "note": "Phone-call and same-device virtual-meeting limitations across iOS and Android." }, { "label": "Read AI speaker editing", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/36169538719379-Can-I-edit-text-and-speaker-names-in-my-meeting-report", "note": "Generic same-room labels plus transcript-wide speaker renaming and turn reassignment." } ] } }, { "key": "recordings", "label": "Recordings, playback, and clips", "lead": "tl;dv has broader documented support for recordings, playback, and clips.", "analysis": "tl;dv: Bot recordings support video, transcript, clips, reels, and shareable moments. Bot-free recordings are audio-only and omit video, screen sharing, and chat. Read AI: Pro and free users can receive notes and transcripts, but source media is not a durable playback library. Read documents a 30-day grace period before lower-tier media deletion.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Rich playback, clips, and reels—with a botless video caveat", "detail": "Bot recordings support video, transcript, clips, reels, and shareable moments. Bot-free recordings are audio-only and omit video, screen sharing, and chat.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv bot-free recording", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/14433337-recording-without-a-bot", "note": "Desktop capture and the audio-only limitation." }, { "label": "tl;dv free-plan limits", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8919450-what-are-the-limits-of-the-free-plan", "note": "Recording retention, archive behavior, AI-note coverage, lifetime credits, meeting duration, and concurrency." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Playback only on Enterprise and Enterprise+", "detail": "Pro and free users can receive notes and transcripts, but source media is not a durable playback library. Read documents a 30-day grace period before lower-tier media deletion.", "level": "limited", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI recording availability", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/15107171454739-Why-can-t-I-see-recordings-in-my-report-when-I-received-a-recording-notification-in-my-meeting", "note": "Enterprise playback requirement and lower-plan source-media deletion." }, { "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." } ] } }, { "key": "notesAndSearch", "label": "Notes, action items, and search", "lead": "Both products document broad support for notes, action items, and search, with different scope and plan limits.", "analysis": "tl;dv: The product is particularly good at synthesizing multiple meetings and turning recurring prompts into reports, including action lists grouped by person and date. Those are report or checklist outputs rather than a native task lifecycle with workspace queues and completion state. Free accounts get a limited number of AI notes. Read AI: Read’s differentiated layer is live and post-meeting intelligence: engagement, sentiment, speaker stats, action items, and search across connected content. Recommendations can resurface recent work assigned to the user, but Read does not document a full workspace-wide task board with assignee and completion management comparable to dedicated action trackers.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "AI notes, action digests, multi-meeting reports, and topic tracking", "detail": "The product is particularly good at synthesizing multiple meetings and turning recurring prompts into reports, including action lists grouped by person and date. Those are report or checklist outputs rather than a native task lifecycle with workspace queues and completion state. Free accounts get a limited number of AI notes.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv pricing", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6082483-what-is-tl-dv-s-pricing", "note": "Official Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise pricing and plan scope." }, { "label": "tl;dv free-plan limits", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8919450-what-are-the-limits-of-the-free-plan", "note": "Recording retention, archive behavior, AI-note coverage, lifetime credits, meeting duration, and concurrency." }, { "label": "tl;dv AI prompts", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/9235713-ai-prompts-inspiration", "note": "Cross-meeting action-item reports grouped by participant and date plus common analysis workflows." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Summaries, action items, Search Copilot, and coaching analytics", "detail": "Read’s differentiated layer is live and post-meeting intelligence: engagement, sentiment, speaker stats, action items, and search across connected content. Recommendations can resurface recent work assigned to the user, but Read does not document a full workspace-wide task board with assignee and completion management comparable to dedicated action trackers.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." }, { "label": "Read AI report distribution", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/23219401248019-How-do-I-control-meeting-report-sharing-and-distribution", "note": "Owner-level participant sharing, invitee behavior, email/Slack/Teams recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and workspace controls." } ] } }, { "key": "companyMemory", "label": "People, companies, and context", "lead": "Read AI has broader documented support for people, companies, and context.", "analysis": "tl;dv: tl;dv can query and report across accessible meetings, but it does not present a broader email/calendar/person/company relationship memory as its core model. Read AI: Search can span meetings, email, messages, and documents, which is broader than a transcript library. The experience is a search layer rather than explicit relationship timelines and upcoming-event pages.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Meeting library and multi-meeting synthesis", "detail": "tl;dv can query and report across accessible meetings, but it does not present a broader email/calendar/person/company relationship memory as its core model.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv MCP", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15322415-mcp", "note": "Plan eligibility, tools, access model, and result behavior." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Cross-source Search Copilot", "detail": "Search can span meetings, email, messages, and documents, which is broader than a transcript library. The experience is a search layer rather than explicit relationship timelines and upcoming-event pages.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." } ] } }, { "key": "sharing", "label": "Automatic sharing and workspace defaults", "lead": "Both products document broad support for automatic sharing and workspace defaults, with different scope and plan limits.", "analysis": "tl;dv: Teams can automatically share with participants, publish to a team or organization library, and apply admin privacy rules using meeting context such as title, internal or external type, and team role. Sensitive categories can remain private by rule. Read AI: Workspace admins can set automatic report access for internal or external participants and give teams role-based access to matching reports, including retroactive access. Owners can send recaps and recurring-meeting pre-reads through email, Slack, or Teams. Participant rules use calendar invitees, including no-shows, and the owner’s settings govern each report, so teams should configure workspace controls deliberately.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Granular team privacy defaults and automatic sharing", "detail": "Teams can automatically share with participants, publish to a team or organization library, and apply admin privacy rules using meeting context such as title, internal or external type, and team role. Sensitive categories can remain private by rule.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv team privacy defaults", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15033798-team-privacy-defaults", "note": "Admin-controlled automatic sharing, workspace-library publishing, and privacy rules for sensitive meetings." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Workspace-wide participant and team report access", "detail": "Workspace admins can set automatic report access for internal or external participants and give teams role-based access to matching reports, including retroactive access. Owners can send recaps and recurring-meeting pre-reads through email, Slack, or Teams. Participant rules use calendar invitees, including no-shows, and the owner’s settings govern each report, so teams should configure workspace controls deliberately.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI workspace sharing settings", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/7962819152659-What-are-all-of-the-settings-and-permissions-available-with-Workspaces", "note": "Participant auto-sharing, team report access, and workspace distribution controls." }, { "label": "Read AI report distribution", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/23219401248019-How-do-I-control-meeting-report-sharing-and-distribution", "note": "Owner-level participant sharing, invitee behavior, email/Slack/Teams recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and workspace controls." } ] } }, { "key": "automations", "label": "Automations", "lead": "tl;dv has broader documented support for automations.", "analysis": "tl;dv: Automated multi-meeting reports, playbooks, CRM updates, and conditional Slack posts are useful, especially for customer-facing teams. Slack workflows can format decisions and action items with owners and deadlines, but team workflow scope excludes team admins and billing-group admins, and the overall system is less open-ended than a general meeting condition/action builder. Read AI: Read can send post-meeting recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and scheduled topic updates, while Ask Read actions can draft and send email, create calendar events, and update HubSpot after user approval. It is more opinionated around its own agents and intelligence outputs than a general meeting trigger/condition/action canvas.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Recurring AI reports and sales workflows", "detail": "Automated multi-meeting reports, playbooks, CRM updates, and conditional Slack posts are useful, especially for customer-facing teams. Slack workflows can format decisions and action items with owners and deadlines, but team workflow scope excludes team admins and billing-group admins, and the overall system is less open-ended than a general meeting condition/action builder.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv pricing", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6082483-what-is-tl-dv-s-pricing", "note": "Official Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise pricing and plan scope." }, { "label": "tl;dv Slack workflows", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/5946410-set-up-the-slack-integration", "note": "Conditional automatic summaries, decisions, and owner/deadline action lists plus the team-admin scope exception." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Recaps, pre-reads, scheduled updates, and agent actions", "detail": "Read can send post-meeting recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and scheduled topic updates, while Ask Read actions can draft and send email, create calendar events, and update HubSpot after user approval. It is more opinionated around its own agents and intelligence outputs than a general meeting trigger/condition/action canvas.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI report distribution", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/23219401248019-How-do-I-control-meeting-report-sharing-and-distribution", "note": "Owner-level participant sharing, invitee behavior, email/Slack/Teams recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and workspace controls." }, { "label": "Read AI actions", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/48863788829971-Using-Ask-Read-actions", "note": "Agent actions for HubSpot updates, approved email sending, calendar creation, and scheduled reports." } ] } }, { "key": "integrations", "label": "Integrations", "lead": "Read AI has broader documented support for integrations.", "analysis": "tl;dv: tl;dv connects to common CRMs and work tools; exact access varies by plan. The catalog is oriented around GTM and collaboration workflows. Read AI: Search Copilot’s cross-source coverage is a strength, although connector eligibility varies by paid plan.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "CRM and collaboration integrations on paid plans", "detail": "tl;dv connects to common CRMs and work tools; exact access varies by plan. The catalog is oriented around GTM and collaboration workflows.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv pricing", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6082483-what-is-tl-dv-s-pricing", "note": "Official Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise pricing and plan scope." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Calendar, conferencing, email, messaging, documents, and premium connectors", "detail": "Search Copilot’s cross-source coverage is a strength, although connector eligibility varies by paid plan.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." } ] } }, { "key": "agentsAndApi", "label": "API, MCP, CLI, and data portability", "lead": "Both products support API, MCP, CLI, and data portability, with different scope and plan limits.", "analysis": "tl;dv: MCP can search meetings and participants, with typical result sets capped at 50. A subtle access rule matters: viewing a shared meeting is not enough if its organizer is on Free—the organizer must have Pro or higher before that meeting is available through MCP or the API. The API is documented as v1alpha1 and includes recording downloads, so integration teams should expect contract evolution. Read AI: Read’s API and remote MCP can return meeting metadata, participants, summaries, chapters, action items, topics, metrics, full speaker-labeled transcripts, and recording-download URLs. They are open beta, use browser OAuth with short-lived rotating tokens, lack service credentials and file upload, and only reach reports the user can access unless an admin enables global report access.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "MCP on Pro+ and a public alpha API", "detail": "MCP can search meetings and participants, with typical result sets capped at 50. A subtle access rule matters: viewing a shared meeting is not enough if its organizer is on Free—the organizer must have Pro or higher before that meeting is available through MCP or the API. The API is documented as v1alpha1 and includes recording downloads, so integration teams should expect contract evolution.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv MCP", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15322415-mcp", "note": "Plan eligibility, tools, access model, and result behavior." }, { "label": "tl;dv API", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/11583137-api", "note": "Pro/Business eligibility and v1alpha1 status." }, { "label": "tl;dv download limits", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/5946213-how-to-download-your-recording", "note": "No bulk export plus paid-plan, ownership, and permission requirements for individual recording downloads." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Open-beta REST API and MCP with full meeting reports", "detail": "Read’s API and remote MCP can return meeting metadata, participants, summaries, chapters, action items, topics, metrics, full speaker-labeled transcripts, and recording-download URLs. They are open beta, use browser OAuth with short-lived rotating tokens, lack service credentials and file upload, and only reach reports the user can access unless an admin enables global report access.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI API and MCP overview", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/49379985941523-Read-AI-API-and-MCP-Overview", "note": "Open-beta scope, prerequisites, OAuth and rate-limit constraints, permissions, and current feature gaps." }, { "label": "Read AI MCP tools", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/49381158409491-MCP-Server", "note": "Full transcript, summary, action, metric, recording-download, agent-dispatch, and sharing tools." } ] } }, { "key": "admin", "label": "Security, privacy, and admin", "lead": "Read AI has broader documented support for security, privacy, and admin.", "analysis": "tl;dv: Paid Teams add roles, billing administration, and forward-looking defaults; team settings do not override Team Admins. The separate domain-based Organization has no organization-wide admin defaults, any same-domain user can join it, and it cannot be deleted. Multi-team management is Business-only. Read AI: Retention, domain controls, SAML, and HIPAA-related capabilities are concentrated in Enterprise+. That plan currently carries a five-license minimum.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Paid Team controls, with a looser domain Organization layer", "detail": "Paid Teams add roles, billing administration, and forward-looking defaults; team settings do not override Team Admins. The separate domain-based Organization has no organization-wide admin defaults, any same-domain user can join it, and it cannot be deleted. Multi-team management is Business-only.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv pricing", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6082483-what-is-tl-dv-s-pricing", "note": "Official Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise pricing and plan scope." }, { "label": "tl;dv team privacy defaults", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15033798-team-privacy-defaults", "note": "Admin-controlled automatic sharing, workspace-library publishing, and privacy rules for sensitive meetings." }, { "label": "tl;dv organization and team model", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8975481-organization-vs-team-what-s-the-difference", "note": "Automatic same-domain Organization membership, absence of Organization-wide admin defaults, and the paid Team hierarchy." }, { "label": "tl;dv permission levels", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/10131073-understanding-permission-levels", "note": "Team roles, admin behavior, and the non-deletable domain Organization." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Core admin on Enterprise; advanced governance on Enterprise+", "detail": "Retention, domain controls, SAML, and HIPAA-related capabilities are concentrated in Enterprise+. That plan currently carries a five-license minimum.", "level": "strong", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." }, { "label": "Read AI workspace sharing settings", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/7962819152659-What-are-all-of-the-settings-and-permissions-available-with-Workspaces", "note": "Participant auto-sharing, team report access, and workspace distribution controls." }, { "label": "Read AI workspace offboarding", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/27433066427283-How-do-I-offboard-someone-from-my-Read-workspace", "note": "Account deactivation, report transfer, and the limits of simply removing a workspace member." }, { "label": "Read AI data handling", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/52055801266579-What-Does-Read-AI-Do-With-My-Data-Read-AI", "note": "Storage, access, AI-training consent, and the opt-out Customer Experience Improvement Program." } ] } }, { "key": "languages", "label": "Languages", "lead": "Both products support languages, with different scope and plan limits.", "analysis": "tl;dv: Language selection behavior varies by capture mode, and the multilingual Whisper option is documented for Business and Enterprise. Read AI: Read’s current pricing page uses “20+ languages” in the Free plan card but “16+ languages” in the detailed comparison table. The coverage is useful but materially narrower on paper than competitors advertising 75 or 100+; verify the language you need rather than relying on the headline count.", "productA": { "id": "tldv", "name": "tl;dv", "summary": "Multilingual transcription; advanced multilingual mode is plan-gated", "detail": "Language selection behavior varies by capture mode, and the multilingual Whisper option is documented for Business and Enterprise.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "tl;dv pricing", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6082483-what-is-tl-dv-s-pricing", "note": "Official Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise pricing and plan scope." }, { "label": "tl;dv bot-free recording", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/14433337-recording-without-a-bot", "note": "Desktop capture and the audio-only limitation." } ] }, "productB": { "id": "read-ai", "name": "Read AI", "summary": "Read’s pricing page says 20+; its detail table says 16+", "detail": "Read’s current pricing page uses “20+ languages” in the Free plan card but “16+ languages” in the detailed comparison table. The coverage is useful but materially narrower on paper than competitors advertising 75 or 100+; verify the language you need rather than relying on the headline count.", "level": "available", "sources": [ { "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." } ] } } ], "directComparison": null, "thirdOption": { "product": { "id": "circleback", "name": "Circleback", "shortName": "Circleback", "logoPath": "/logos/circleback_square.png", "website": "https://circleback.ai", "tagline": "Every meeting becomes useful company memory.", "positioning": "Circleback turns online meetings, in-person conversations, and imported calls into one shared company memory. Record with a bot, with the botless desktop app, from an iPhone or Android phone, or on Apple Watch. Every route produces the same speaker-labeled record, detailed notes designed to stand alone, and automatically assigned action items. Sharing rules and automations carry the useful parts into the teams and tools that need them. Circleback is built for people and AI agents: the complete meeting record available to a person is also available programmatically through its API, MCP, and CLI.", "bestFor": "Companies that want one shared meeting system across sales, product, engineering, recruiting, customer success, and leadership—with automatic sharing, function-specific workflows, and complete data for people, agents, and their own software.", "lessIdealFor": "A team that only wants a cheap transcript now and then, or a sales organization buying mainly for forecasting and rep coaching.", "decisionSummary": { "fit": "Every meeting becomes shared, useful company memory", "chooseFor": [ "Detailed notes; always speaker-labeled", "People and AI agents; leading security" ], "watchFor": [ "Paid plans are per user", "Not a forecasting suite" ] }, "pricing": { "headline": "Free; Pro from $15/user/month annually; Business from $25/user/month annually; Enterprise $35/user/month, billed annually", "detail": "Free includes unlimited meetings and members with 30 days of meeting and recording history, limited automations, and API, MCP, and CLI access. Pro adds automations with all integrations, including Notion, HubSpot, Salesforce, Attio, webhooks, and many more apps, plus custom AI insights. Paid prices are per user/month: Pro is $15 with annual billing or $18 month-to-month; Business is $25 or $29; Enterprise is $35 with annual billing only. See https://circleback.ai/pricing for current plan packaging.", "freePlan": "Free includes unlimited meetings and members, with 30 days of meeting and recording history, limited automations, and API, MCP, and CLI access." }, "strengths": [ "Online, in-person, phone, desktop, mobile, Watch, bot, and botless capture all produce a speaker-labeled transcript; every route can keep its recording or discard it after notes are made.", "The notes are detailed enough to stand alone, while automatically assigned action items stay trackable across the workspace and can become issues in Linear or another work tracker.", "Conditional automatic sharing, company context, free viewers, enforced defaults, and actions in connected apps make each meeting useful beyond the person who recorded it.", "Circleback is built for people and AI agents. The complete meeting record available to a person—including the recording, full speaker-labeled transcript, notes, action items, attendees, people, and companies—is also available programmatically through the public API, MCP, and CLI.", "Industry-leading security practices include encryption at rest and in transit, SOC 2 Type II, EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework certification, GDPR support, and HIPAA compliance. Customer data is never used to train models, and an external infrastructure pentest report is available through the security portal." ], "tradeoffs": [ "The Free plan has shorter history and limited automations. Pro adds automations with all integrations, including Notion, HubSpot, Salesforce, Attio, webhooks, and many more apps, plus custom AI insights. A solo user who only wants occasional transcripts may find a more generous free recorder elsewhere.", "It is not a sales forecasting suite. Gong goes further on deal inspection, rep coaching, and forecasting.", "It is not a live meeting coach. Read AI goes further on real-time engagement and sentiment signals, while Krisp specializes in cleaning up audio before it reaches the transcript.", "Circleback’s primary processing operations are in the United States. A company with a hard regional-hosting or on-premises requirement should confirm fit during security review." ], "chooseIf": [ "You want the same speaker-labeled record from an online call, a room, a phone recording, or your Watch.", "You want notes designed to stand alone and follow-through that does not disappear inside each meeting: assigned action items, one workspace-wide list, and a path into your issue tracker.", "You want Circleback to look things up and do the next step in the apps where your team works.", "You want coworkers, ChatGPT, Claude, other agents, and your own tools to use the same company context." ], "features": { "capture": { "summary": "Any meeting, with the same speaker-labeled result", "detail": "Use the meeting bot for scheduled Zoom, Google Meet, Teams, and Webex calls; record locally from macOS or Windows with no bot; use iPhone, Android, or Apple Watch in person; or import a phone call or existing file. Whichever path you take, Circleback processes it into a speaker-labeled transcript, notes, and action items in the same workspace.", "level": "strong" }, "platforms": { "summary": "Web, macOS, Windows, iOS, Android, and Apple Watch", "detail": "Desktop apps handle bot-free system audio and video. The iOS and Android apps record in-person conversations and include Assistant. Apple Watch can record from your wrist without the iPhone nearby, then sends the meeting through the same transcription and notes pipeline.", "level": "strong" }, "inPerson": { "summary": "Phone, desktop, or Watch—with speaker labels", "detail": "Record an in-person meeting from iOS, Android, macOS, Windows, or Apple Watch. Circleback separates and labels the speakers instead of returning one undifferentiated wall of text. Imported phone recordings get the same treatment.", "level": "strong" }, "recordings": { "summary": "A recording when you want one; notes-only when you do not", "detail": "Every capture route can keep the source recording with the meeting. Play it beside the transcript, download it, link to a moment, or make a clip. If you only want notes and the speaker-labeled transcript, turn recording storage off.", "level": "strong" }, "notesAndSearch": { "summary": "Detailed standalone notes, assigned action items, and cited search", "detail": "Our editorial judgment is that Circleback’s notes are more detailed and need less transcript archaeology than the short recaps common in meeting tools. It automatically creates action items, assigns each one to an owner when the conversation makes the owner clear, and gathers work from every meeting in a workspace-wide view where it can be filtered and marked done. Custom insights extract the fields a team cares about, while Assistant searches meetings and connected email with citations.", "level": "strong" }, "companyMemory": { "summary": "A shared company memory, not isolated meeting pages", "detail": "Person and company pages combine rolling summaries, relationship timelines, emails, meetings, attendees, and upcoming events. Search and Assistant work across that context, so a conversation stays useful to the next person and the next team.", "level": "strong" }, "sharing": { "summary": "Conditional automatic sharing with workspace safeguards", "detail": "Automations can share matching meetings with specific people, teams, or the whole workspace based on titles, participants, invitee emails or domains, tags, and combined conditions. Admins can set or enforce default sharing access while members retain explicit controls for private or sensitive conversations.", "level": "strong" }, "automations": { "summary": "One automation layer for every function", "detail": "Run actions when meetings match conditions, extract the fields each team cares about, share notes, and route the result into the system where work happens. Sales can update the CRM; product and research can collect themes; engineering can open assigned issues in Linear or another tracker; recruiting and customer teams can route structured follow-up. Automations also post to Slack, call webhooks, and re-run against older meetings.", "level": "strong" }, "integrations": { "summary": "Search other apps, then do the work there", "detail": "Circleback Assistant can look up context and take actions in tools such as Linear, Notion, Asana, HubSpot, PostHog, Attio, Ashby, and Intercom. Automations can create Linear issues from assigned meeting action items, write action items to monday.com, and send outcomes to Slack, Salesforce, Zoho, and more. Zapier, Make, webhooks, and custom MCP servers cover the long tail.", "level": "strong" }, "agentsAndApi": { "summary": "The same complete meeting data for people and AI agents", "detail": "Circleback is built for people and AI agents. The complete meeting record a person can access—its full speaker-labeled transcript, recording, notes, action items, metadata, attendees, and related people and companies—is also available programmatically through the public API, MCP, and CLI. The API also supports action-item updates. MCP and CLI are read-only and add search and retrieval across meetings, transcripts, action items, calendars, email, people, companies, and tags. Use the stack from ChatGPT or Claude, build internal tools, or receive meeting payloads by webhook.", "level": "strong" }, "admin": { "summary": "Industry-leading security, privacy, and governance", "detail": "Customer data is encrypted at rest and in transit and never used to train models. Circleback is SOC 2 Type II, certified under the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework, supports GDPR obligations, and is HIPAA-compliant with BAAs available. The security portal includes compliance materials and an external infrastructure pentest report. Available controls include single sign-on (SAML or OIDC) and SCIM provisioning, configurable data retention and recording storage, enforced workspace and sharing settings, teams and roles, domain and API key access controls, centralized billing, usage reporting, and free viewer seats.", "level": "strong" }, "languages": { "summary": "100+ transcription languages", "detail": "Users can choose from more than 100 meeting languages and separately control the output language used for generated notes.", "level": "strong" } }, "sources": [ { "label": "Circleback product guide", "url": "https://circleback.ai/llms.txt", "note": "Capture modes, apps, search, automations, integrations, recordings, MCP, CLI, webhooks, and security resources." }, { "label": "Circleback pricing", "url": "https://circleback.ai/pricing", "note": "Current plan prices, included features, Business controls, Enterprise options, and free viewer seats." }, { "label": "Circleback recording guide", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/11090138-getting-started-with-recording", "note": "Desktop, mobile, bot, and import capture paths for online and in-person conversations." }, { "label": "Circleback optional recording storage", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/10581965-configure-whether-meeting-recordings-are-saved", "note": "Keep notes, action items, transcript, and insights while disabling stored audio and video." }, { "label": "Circleback mobile and Apple Watch apps", "url": "https://circleback.ai/mobile", "note": "iOS, Android, and Apple Watch capture for in-person meetings and conversations." }, { "label": "Circleback public API", "url": "https://circleback.ai/docs/api", "note": "Programmatic access to the complete meeting record available in Circleback, including notes, action items, transcripts, recordings, people, and companies." }, { "label": "Circleback MCP documentation", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/13249081-circleback-mcp", "note": "Read-only access from ChatGPT, Claude, Cursor, Codex, and other MCP clients to meetings, transcripts, action items, people, companies, calendar, email, and tags." }, { "label": "Circleback CLI documentation", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/14677613-circleback-cli", "note": "Command-line and JSON access to meetings, speaker-labeled transcripts, action items, calendars, email, people, companies, and cross-meeting action-item search." }, { "label": "Circleback Assistant connectors", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/13615023-ask-circleback-assistant", "note": "Search and take action in connected work apps from Circleback Assistant." }, { "label": "Circleback automatic sharing", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/10460582-automatically-share-meetings-with-your-workspace", "note": "Conditional sharing by meeting title, participants, invitee emails or domains, and tags to people, teams, or the workspace." }, { "label": "Circleback enforced workspace settings", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/11095989-default-and-enforced-workspace-settings", "note": "Admin-controlled defaults for sharing access, recording storage, joining preferences, and other meeting settings." }, { "label": "Circleback security and data processing", "url": "https://circleback.ai/dpa", "note": "Retention responsibilities, subprocessors, and United States primary processing operations." }, { "label": "Circleback security overview", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/10460553-security", "note": "Encryption at rest and in transit, SOC 2 Type II, no-training commitment, GDPR support, HIPAA compliance and BAA availability, EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework certification, and an external infrastructure pentest." }, { "label": "Circleback security portal", "url": "https://security.circleback.ai/", "note": "Compliance materials, security controls, subprocessors, and an external infrastructure pentest report." }, { "label": "Circleback action items in Linear", "url": "https://support.circleback.ai/en/articles/13622158-integrate-with-linear", "note": "Automatically create Linear issues from meeting action items and preserve the matched assignee." } ] }, "label": "A third option to consider" }, "faqs": [ { "question": "Which is better: tl;dv or Read AI?", "answer": "tl;dv centers recordings, clips, reports, and playbooks. Read AI centers live engagement and sentiment analytics, coaching metrics, and search across connected work sources." }, { "question": "Which is less expensive, tl;dv or Read AI?", "answer": "tl;dv: Free; Pro from $18/user/month annually; Business from $29 annually. Read AI: Free for 5 meetings/month; Pro from $15/user/month annually. Compare the paid seats, included usage, recording access, and admin features you actually need." }, { "question": "Can tl;dv and Read AI record without a bot?", "answer": "tl;dv: Meeting bot or bot-free desktop recording. Read AI: Meeting bot, macOS/Windows desktop, and mobile. The useful check is whether your required capture mode keeps video, a recording, and speaker names." }, { "question": "Which is better for a whole company?", "answer": "First ask who gets each note automatically; otherwise useful context stays with the recorder. Then compare permissions, retention, and enforced defaults. tl;dv: Granular team privacy defaults and automatic sharing. Read AI: Workspace-wide participant and team report access." }, { "question": "Can I access and move the full meeting data?", "answer": "tl;dv: MCP on Pro+ and a public alpha API. Read AI: Open-beta REST API and MCP with full meeting reports. Check the selected plan, authentication model, transcript scope, export format, and retention window for the workflow you need." }, { "question": "How was this comparison researched?", "answer": "We use first-party pricing pages, product pages, help docs, and release notes for both products. The sources are linked below." } ], "variableMeasured": [ "Capture options", "Desktop and mobile", "In-person capture and speaker labels", "Recordings, playback, and clips", "Notes, action items, and search", "People, companies, and context", "Automatic sharing and workspace defaults", "Automations", "Integrations", "API, MCP, CLI, and data portability", "Security, privacy, and admin", "Languages" ], "sources": [ { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv pricing", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6082483-what-is-tl-dv-s-pricing", "note": "Official Free, Pro, Business, and Enterprise pricing and plan scope." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv free-plan limits", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8919450-what-are-the-limits-of-the-free-plan", "note": "Recording retention, archive behavior, AI-note coverage, lifetime credits, meeting duration, and concurrency." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv mobile app", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8490450-mobile-app", "note": "Recently launched early-stage mobile recording for in-person meetings." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv speaker identification", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/6171907-speaker-identification-in-transcript", "note": "General automatic speaker identification; the article does not document mobile-mode parity." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv bot-free recording", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/14433337-recording-without-a-bot", "note": "Desktop capture and the audio-only limitation." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv MCP", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15322415-mcp", "note": "Plan eligibility, tools, access model, and result behavior." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv API", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/11583137-api", "note": "Pro/Business eligibility and v1alpha1 status." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv team privacy defaults", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/15033798-team-privacy-defaults", "note": "Admin-controlled automatic sharing, workspace-library publishing, and privacy rules for sensitive meetings." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv download limits", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/5946213-how-to-download-your-recording", "note": "No bulk export plus paid-plan, ownership, and permission requirements for individual recording downloads." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv organization and team model", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/8975481-organization-vs-team-what-s-the-difference", "note": "Automatic same-domain Organization membership, absence of Organization-wide admin defaults, and the paid Team hierarchy." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv permission levels", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/10131073-understanding-permission-levels", "note": "Team roles, admin behavior, and the non-deletable domain Organization." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv AI prompts", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/9235713-ai-prompts-inspiration", "note": "Cross-meeting action-item reports grouped by participant and date plus common analysis workflows." }, { "productId": "tldv", "productName": "tl;dv", "label": "tl;dv Slack workflows", "url": "https://intercom.help/tldv/en/articles/5946410-set-up-the-slack-integration", "note": "Conditional automatic summaries, decisions, and owner/deadline action lists plus the team-admin scope exception." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI pricing", "url": "https://www.read.ai/plans-pricing", "note": "Current meeting limits, prices, languages, playback gate, governance, and Enterprise+ minimum." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI desktop app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/45911611006995-How-to-Use-Read-s-Desktop-App-for-Windows-and-Mac", "note": "Device-audio recording and participant disclosure behavior." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI iPhone app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/34467337929107-Read-AI-App-for-iPhone", "note": "In-person real-time transcript and summary." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI Android app", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/51863250182291-Read-AI-App-for-Android", "note": "Android in-person capture, live transcript and summary, and report access." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI mobile capture limits", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/51863422605203-Can-I-use-Read-s-mobile-app-to-record-calls-from-my-phone", "note": "Phone-call and same-device virtual-meeting limitations across iOS and Android." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI speaker editing", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/36169538719379-Can-I-edit-text-and-speaker-names-in-my-meeting-report", "note": "Generic same-room labels plus transcript-wide speaker renaming and turn reassignment." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI recording availability", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/15107171454739-Why-can-t-I-see-recordings-in-my-report-when-I-received-a-recording-notification-in-my-meeting", "note": "Enterprise playback requirement and lower-plan source-media deletion." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI workspace sharing settings", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/7962819152659-What-are-all-of-the-settings-and-permissions-available-with-Workspaces", "note": "Participant auto-sharing, team report access, and workspace distribution controls." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI report distribution", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/23219401248019-How-do-I-control-meeting-report-sharing-and-distribution", "note": "Owner-level participant sharing, invitee behavior, email/Slack/Teams recaps, recurring-meeting pre-reads, and workspace controls." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI actions", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/48863788829971-Using-Ask-Read-actions", "note": "Agent actions for HubSpot updates, approved email sending, calendar creation, and scheduled reports." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI API and MCP overview", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/49379985941523-Read-AI-API-and-MCP-Overview", "note": "Open-beta scope, prerequisites, OAuth and rate-limit constraints, permissions, and current feature gaps." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI MCP tools", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/49381158409491-MCP-Server", "note": "Full transcript, summary, action, metric, recording-download, agent-dispatch, and sharing tools." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI data handling", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/52055801266579-What-Does-Read-AI-Do-With-My-Data-Read-AI", "note": "Storage, access, AI-training consent, and the opt-out Customer Experience Improvement Program." }, { "productId": "read-ai", "productName": "Read AI", "label": "Read AI workspace offboarding", "url": "https://support.read.ai/hc/en-us/articles/27433066427283-How-do-I-offboard-someone-from-my-Read-workspace", "note": "Account deactivation, report transfer, and the limits of simply removing a workspace member." } ], "methodology": { "approach": "First-party pricing, product documentation, help-center articles, and release notes. Capability levels describe documented breadth, not overall product quality. Competitor strengths and material plan or capture-mode limits are both included. No pay-to-play rankings.", "ratingLabels": { "strong": "Broad support", "available": "Available with limits", "limited": "Narrow or indirect", "not-available": "Not documented" }, "ratingScale": { "strong": "Broad native support across the product or relevant paid plans.", "available": "Documented support with meaningful scope, mode, or plan limits.", "limited": "Narrow, indirect, beta, or substantially plan-gated support.", "not-available": "No current first-party documentation for a native option." }, "claimLevelEvidence": "Each feature dimension includes the exact first-party sources used for both products.", "limitations": "Prices and features change. Check the linked sources and test both products on real calls." } }